There are few topics in PC hardware as complex and misunderstood as cooling. And yet, it is incredibly important; the way that your PC is cooled will impact its performance, longevity, and noise levels. Unfortunately, not everyone knows how to adequately cool their PC, or what the differences are between the various methods of cooling out there.
Is liquid cooling worth it? Is air cooling enough for your PC? How do you even choose?
Let’s find out.
Table of Contents
- Understanding cooling types
- What’s the difference between closed loop and custom loop?
- The Showdown
Understanding cooling types
Before we determine the winner of liquid vs air cooling, we need to cover each of the cooling types.
Air cooling is the cheapest and most common cooling type. In this context, we’ll be referring to “air cooling” as coolers for individual components, rather than the system at large. (Even liquid cooling setups need radiators and intake fans, in the same way that air-cooled systems do.)
The main difference in air vs water cooling is the presence of a heatsink. The purpose of a heatsink is to dissipate heat, with or without a fan attached. Having a fan is usually best, though, as it will allow the heatsink to be directly cooled and help remove hot air from the chassis in question.
In general: the larger the heatsink and the more powerful the fan, the better the cooling performance. Liquid cooling actually works under a similar logic, which we’ll get to in a moment.
Liquid cooling (closed loop)
Closed-loop liquid cooling is achieved through the use of all-in-one (AIO) liquid coolers. These don’t require much extra setup for the users, just a place to mount the radiator. These radiators correspond to fan size and start at 120mm. Some radiators will be longer and take up more fan slots, but also provide better cooling performance in turn.
Any form of liquid cooling will be more expensive than air cooling, but this is where the price disparity starts. We’ll dive deeper into the performance differences later, but the same wisdom applies here. The more surface area (liquid and radiator) and fan strength, the better the overall cooling performance will be.
Liquid cooling (custom loop)
Last but certainly not least is custom loop liquid cooling. This is the most expensive and difficult setup to get running, especially for a first-timer. It also requires the most long-term maintenance, and the largest chassis to get working. In addition to setting up your own tubing, you’ll also need a dedicated pump and reservoir. Many setups will also employ multiple radiators.
The same general rules described above apply here. More surface area dedicated to cooling = better cooling performance.
What’s the difference between closed loop and custom loop?
Closed loop (AIO) and custom loop setups greatly differ in terms of performance and required setup, maintenance, space, etc. To more easily understand the difference, we’ll put it this way:
- A closed loop cooler is all-in-one. Radiator, cooler, loop– all handled for you. Just mount them appropriately and you can pretty much forget it.
- A custom loop cooling system is custom. You’ll need to buy each of your components and assemble them yourself. We’ll dive into why anyone would want to do this below.
Two (technically three) will enter! One will leave!
Now it’s time to pit these cooling methods head-to-head…in a death battle!
Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Cooling performance
To the surprise of absolutely no one, the battle of liquid vs air cooling is won by…
It’s true. Unless you’re using a custom loop setup, that is, which far exceed any air cooling setup in performance. (That’s what we meant earlier about why anyone would go to the trouble of a custom loop.)
But in terms of raw cooling performance, especially between a store-bought liquid cooler vs air cooler, the air cooler will come out on top. At least, so long as it has the appropriate heatsink and fan to work with.
The winner is air cooling for store-bought products. Liquid cooling only wins if you’re willing to do a custom loop.
Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Noise
Now, what about noise levels?
Liquid cooling wins… usually. The issue is, noise isn’t generated by a radiator or heatsink: it’s generated by a fan, which both of these need to function at peak performance. Fortunately, there are an ample amount of quiet PC fans on the market that you can use with either an air cooling or liquid cooling setup.
Liquid cooling still wins, though. That’s because you can run your fans lower while still achieving the same or better cooling performance when compared to an air cooler. As long as you’re willing to invest in high-quality fans, either method will work for keeping a quiet PC. If you want that extra edge, though, then go liquid.
Assuming you’re using the same fans and achieving the same temperatures, a water cooled vs air cooled system will be quieter.
Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Price
This one is pretty clear-cut.
Air cooling wins in pretty much every way here. The cheapest AIO liquid cooling setups can cost as much as the best air coolers on the market. If price is your concern in this battle, then water cooling vs air cooling isn’t even a competition. Air cooling always wins.
Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Size
This one is… a wee bit complicated.
For the sake of argument, let’s assume you want good cooling performance, in addition to a small size. This would dismiss abysmal coolers, like the Intel stock cooler, which is very low profile, but also kinda bad, especially once it has a few years under its belt.
In this case, liquid cooling wins. You can get an AIO setup that will only take up the space of about one 120mm fan inside your chassis (with the radiator), some tubing, and the very low-profile part that actually touches your CPU.
If you don’t have the room to mount even a small radiator, though, an air cooler with a proper heatsink may be the better option, especially if your PC is deep enough.
Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Final Verdict
So…who wins? As always, the answer is… it depends. We’ll help you choose, though.
- If you want the best possible cooling performance, and money/time aren’t an object, then custom loop liquid cooling is your best option. As long as you have the requirements to pull it off, you can’t beat the cooling and aesthetics here.
- If you want great cooling performance and your rig is spacious enough for a thick heatsink, then air cooling is your best option.
- If you want good-to-great cooling performance without spending too much money, then air cooling is your best option.
- If you want good-to-great cooling performance while keeping noise levels low, then closed-loop liquid cooling is your best option.
And, of course, there’s one reason to get a liquid cooling setup that we haven’t mentioned yet. Arguably the most important of all.
- If you just think liquid cooling looks cool, especially with RGB, then liquid cooling is your best option.